Trinity's second minister, Montgomery Schuyler (1814 - 1896), was born in New York City. He came to Marshall in 1835, entered a hardware business, began a Sunday school, and helped found Trinity. He was ordained and made pastor of Trinity Episcopal Church in1841. In 1842 he founded St. Thomas's Church,
Battle Creek. He founded St John's parish in Buffalo, New York, in 1845 and was rector and dean of Christ Church in St. Louis, Missouri, from 1854 to 1896. He is buried in Marshall's Oakridge Cemetery.